If DeGise doesn’t resign over Jersey City hit-and-run, 42.5k signatures needed for recall


In the event that Jersey City Councilwoman-at-Large Amy DeGise doesn’t resign over a July 19th hit-and-run, 42,523 valid signatures will be needed to force a recall election next year, City Clerk Sean Gallagher said.

By John Heinis/Hudson County View

“As this Council took office on January 1, 2022, a recall cannot be held until after January 1, 2023 and the 50th day preceding the completion of the first year of the term is November 12, 2022,” Gallagher said in an email following an inquiry from HCV.

“According to the Hudson County Superintendent of Elections, there were 170,090 registered voters as of November 2, 2021. 25% of 170,090 is 42,523. Consequently, the petitioners seeking a recall must submit 42,523 valid signatures. In accordance with N.J.S.A. 19:27A-10(a), the petitioners have 160 days from the date that the recall effort receives final approval for circulation from the City Clerk.”

DeGise, a former chair of the Hudson County Democratic Organization and the daughter of County Executive Tom DeGise, successfully ran on Mayor Steven Fulop’s ticket in November.

None of her former running mates, or Fulop, have asked her to step down following a hit-and-run on July 19th around 8 a.m.

During the incident, she hit UberEats bicyclist Andrew Black at the intersection of Martin Luther King Drive and Forrest Street after he ran a red light, CCTV footage shows. The video also indicates that DeGise did not brake during the incident.

Separate surveillance footage of the West District Police District shows that she reported the accident in person around 2 p.m. on the same day.

For the time being, only Jersey City Councilmen James Solomon and Frank “Educational” Gilmore, who defeated candidates on Fulop’s ticket last year, have called for her resignation and Solomon noted that if she doesn’t, she should be recalled.

“I called for a recall if she fails to resign because I don’t think she can serve the public effectively and I will be happy to partner with the community advocates taking the lead,” Solomon stated yesterday.

Since stating through spokesman Phil Swibinski that she has no plans to step down last week, the councilwoman has had a historically bad seven days.

On Friday, HCV first reported that she tried to get out of having her car towed in Hoboken by pulling rank and dropping names, to no avail, all caught on police body camera.

On Monday, The Jersey Journal followed up by reporting on her history of unpaid parking tickets, with a spokesman for DeGise stating Wednesday morning that she had received death threats.

That evening, the JJ reported on her living in housing intended for low-income residents, despite her household earning six figures, and then yesterday about her not paying a roughly $3,000 veterinarian bill until the court garnished her wages.

There is currently a recall effort of 5th Ward Councilman Phil Cohen in neighboring Hoboken, though recalls do not have a strong track record in Hudson County.

The most recent one was when Albio Sires was able to recall West New York Mayor Anthony DeFino in 1993, though DeFino and his board of commissioners still ended up winning the special election.

In late 2009, Felix Roque began to try and recall then-West New York Mayor Sal Vega and his commissioners. While the effort was unsuccessful, Roque and his slate swept Vega in the May 2011 municipal elections.

Then-Commissioner Count Wiley spearheaded a recall against Roque in 2012, though the effort fizzled out by early the following year and Team Roque ultimately got re-elected in 2015.

If DeGise were to resign before September 1st of this year, there would be a special election for her seat on November 8th.

In the event she resigned after September 1st, the special election would not be until November 7th, 2023 and the city council would appoint a replacement in the interim.

Warning: A non-numeric value encountered in /home/hcvcp/public_html/wp-content/themes/Hudson County View/includes/wp_booster/td_block.php on line 353


  1. Accident at 8am, reported at 2pm? Are you saying it took her 6 hours to take any action?

    Was she sobriety tested? Maybe you’d wait like that to get a better test result.

    There is a second scandal here. Not just the entitled city councilwoman. The Law Enforcement that is preserving that entitlement by doing nothing. What is their story? Where are the charges 100% of the rest of us would be facing by now?

    • So many concerns here. She took 6 hours to report the incident. I’m quite sure she consulted a lawyer first. (OR – possible she was not sober and needed 6 hours to pass the DUI test?). It’s a felony to leave the scene – why was she not arrested? Surely any other citizen would have been charged. Oh – and she lives in a “low-to-moderate” housing unit all the while maintaining a separate home as well?? With an income (JUST HERS) of over $200,000?? Must be nice. Just sayin’.

  2. It should not be based on the Registered voters but the number of those registered voters who bothered to vote in the last election. That should be the standard especially with all the cemetery voter roles in HC.

  3. Councilwoman DeGise was in the wrong to leave the scene of an accident and deserves to pay the summonses and any other penalties the judge imposes. That said the bicyclist Andrew Black was at fault in this crash and should be issued summonses.I saw at least 4 violations.
    1. He ran a red light
    2. Crossed the double line
    3. Traveled in the wrong traffic lane
    4 Went around cars stopped for a traffic light
    You can call for the resignation of the Councilwoman all you want that is your rite but also call for summonses to be issued to Black and his suspension from Uber Eats for violating traffic ordinances and unsafe driving.

    • She has deep and powerful political connections. He does not.
      She has sworn to a higher standard. He was not.
      She was in an SUV. He was on a bicycle.

  4. I guess when you number the bicyclist’s four heinous crimes against humanity, the councilwoman’s hitting him with her car and leaving him for dead pales in comparison.

  5. Amy Degise is an absolute despicable human being holding an office of power and will be insulated by her colleagues who want the same protection for themselves. Disgusting