Fact check: Bhalla lists 25 accomplishments for first 6 months as Hoboken mayor

3

Earlier this week, Hoboken Mayor Ravi Bhalla listed 25 accomplishments he is proud of since becoming mayor in January. We take a look at the validity of each of those claims. 

By John Heinis/Hudson County View

Each accomplishment will be recognized wuth one of the following terms: completely true, mostly true, half true, mostly false and completely false.

1. Declared Hoboken a Fair and Welcoming City – Completely True

Bhalla’s first act as mayor was signing an executive order declaring Hoboken “a fair and welcoming city” on January 1st.

At the time, he told Hudson County View he opted not to declare Hoboken a sanctuary city since such city’s do not have clearly legally defined terms.

 

2. Secured excellent AA+ credit rating for Hoboken – Mostly false 

While Hoboken definitely received an AA+ credit rating from Standard and Poor’s Global Ratings back in May, but a lot of the credit (pun intended) should go to former Mayor Dawn Zimmer.

Back in 2008, the Mile Square City was just one notch above junk bond status and Zimmer’s tenure in office made a priority of fixing that. Also of note, Hoboken has been at the AA+ ranking since 2013.

 

3. Finalized plans to renovate Madison Street Park – Completely true

Pretty straightforward, the city solidified that upgraded equipment will be coming to the Madison Street Park last month.

 

4. Secured $1,000,000 in transportation funding from State – Mostly true

Hoboken received about a million dollars from the New Jersey Department of Transportation back in February, up over 50 percent from 2017.

However, a significant number of municipalities in the state received a huge upgrade this year under new Democratic Gov. Phil Murphy.

 

5. Advanced final design options for Hoboken’s Northwest Park – Completely true

Public hearings have been held and a fairly comprehensive website was set up prior to the final design options being recently presented.

 

6. Negotiated new plans for hotel in downtown Hoboken – Half true 

In March, Hoboken officials announced that a 17-story, 270-room Hilton Hotel is coming to the waterfront. Bhalla voted no to the project while on the council, citing height concerns which have since been addressed.

This project has been in the works for years and while Bhalla needs to be commended for his collective efforts, both as mayor and on in the council, in this endeavor, but the city council, zoning and planning officials – as well as Zimmer – all lended a hand as well.

 

7. Initiated Multi-Service Center renovation project – Completely true

Bhalla talked a big game during his campaign last year to improving recreation and he has largely delivered thus far. What’s going on with the pool though?

 

8. Expanded fitness in the park to 6 locations – Completely true

See above, again pretty simple and straightforward. Residents seem particularly satisfied with the yoga classes at Southwest Park.

 

9. Saw 10% reduction in overall crime in 2018 compared to 2017 – Half true

Bhalla has made public safety another high priority and has a number of successes to tout on that front, but the credit here for a decline in crime largely belongs to the Hoboken Police Department under the leadership of Chief Kenneth Ferrante.

 

10. Signed executive order to fund public art in Hoboken – Completely true

The local legislation, signed last month, declares that all city bond ordinances shall be drafted to include a provision dedicating one percent towards public art installations.

While not all city officials are convinced this equation will work out, the executive order initially appears to be a step in the right direction for the arts.

 

11. Developed plans for two new dog parks – Completely true

The dog parks, which are coming to the intersections of 2nd and Hudson Streets, as well as 15th and Garden Streets, solicited public input before going to the city planners for some more fine tuning.

 

12. Launched new, user friendly government website: Completely true

The new site, http://www.hobokennj.gov, hit the web last week and is even more comprehensive than its predecessor.

 

13. Created Hoboken Homelessness task force – Completely true

Bhalla announced the new task force last month, which will have City Hall employees working collaboratively with local partners such as CarePoint Health and the Hoboken Shelter.

 

14. Prevented Union Dry Dock from Christie/NJ Transit takeover – Mostly false

While the mayor notes that the fight is still ongoing nearly seven months later, the fact that the NJ Transit board unexpectedly pulled a measure to acquire Union Dry Dock back in January had more to do with Murphy flexing his political muscle than anything else. The mayor played a role, but ultimately did not have much to do with the final say.

Currently, city officials are anxiously awaiting to see what the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers will do with NY Waterway’s proposal to takeover Union Dry Dock. Bhalla has been one of many rallying against such a move.

 

15. Created new office of constituent affairs – Completely true

In May, Bhalla announced that Caroline Caulfield, an aide of U.S. Senator Cory Booker (D-NJ), was heading to City Hall to run the office of constituent affairs. The council didn’t oppose adding the new department.

 

16. Adopted budget with NO tax increase for 2018 –  Half true 

2018 marked another year of stable taxes for the Mile Square City, obviously good news for taxpayers, but the budgeting process involves the administration going back and forth with the city council before the latter ultimately votes on a budget.

Although the mayor always has the opportunity to exercise his veto power, that wasn’t necessary here as the council approved the $118.6 million budget unanimously.

 

17. Invested $5M in water main upgrades, $2.2M in road resurfacing – Completely true

Fairly easy to fact check, though many officials and residents alike remain dismayed by the ongoing issues with Washington Street.

 

18. Planned expansion of composting for residents and businesses – Completely true

Bhalla is a Democrat that leans about as far to the left as humanly possible, so prioritizing environmental issues such as composting should not come as much of a surprise.

 

19. Expanded hours for free tenant advocate service – Completely true

Self-explanatory.

 

20. Improved quality of life and safety during “Leprecon” event – Completely true

Bhalla said this would be a priority during his inauguration speech and didn’t take long to make good on his word. As a result, arrests, injuries and public nuisances were down this year.

 

21. Signed executive order ensuring paid parental leave – Completely true

The mayor signed the local legislation in May, allowing municipal employees to receive their full salary while on parental leave.

 

22. Supported LGTBQ community with gender neutral bathroom executive order – Mostly false

While Bhalla put his John Hancock on this order back in April, all bathroom signage was supposed to be changed by May 31st. On July 17th, it was pointed out that certain signage remained out of date – which is still the case in some instances today.

 

23. Expanded free summer concert series to Southwest Park – Completely true

Another self-explanatory one, Southwest Park is flourishing under this administration.

 

24. Signed into law regulations on single use plastic bags – Mostly true

Bhalla spearheaded this initiative, which many Democrats seem to be doing now, though it did also require council approval to take effect.

 

25. Advanced $230 Million Rebuild by Design project – Mostly false

The New Jersey Department of Environmental Protection, along with engineering firm AECOM, hosted Rebuild by Design workshops in Hoboken in May and June, but this is part of federal guidelines set in place to keep the project moving forward.

While the city certainly has a vested interest in this and certainly aided in the process, with a full-time City Hall employee focused in on the project daily, no formal government action has been taken on the project since last year.

3 COMMENTS

  1. #19 is not completely true. The facts are that the city council increased the funding from 25K to 45K (increase of 20K;) however, the hours have not increased. The intention for the increase was to allow for the tenant advocate to represent residents in court. However, the parameters for which renters get representation and which do not was never defined. Presumably, at present, the Mayor decides in a case-by-case basis. HFHA would strongly recommend that the city council set parameters as this is not a service that should be left to chance. We respectfully request that Hudson County View correct the error.

    • I’m confused: the website says the hours have been increased and regular citizens and other electeds have also said the same. Yet you’re saying the hour were never increased at all in any instances? Are they increased some days and not others?

      • We’re not sure of website to which you refer, but the hours are the same as they’ve always been. The city periodically announces hours, but there has never been a set number. Not sure which regular citizens or electeds are telling you otherwise, but the change made was for an additional 20K in the yearly amount and an open-ended discussion at a city council meeting with no resolution about the tenant advocate representing tenants in court.

        Presumably, because the dollar amount was increased there is an automatic presumption that the hours have thus increased. However, in hour experience 20K can be eaten up in the court system with as few as 1 or 2 cases.

        We are aware of one situation where a tenant was represented by the tenant advocate in court (although the tenant advocate was incorrect in his assessment of the law.)

        It is not uncommon for electeds to present a prettier picture of their support for tenants than they actually have so, perhaps, saying the hours have increased is just part of the same sort of ongoing misrepresentation that tenants in Hoboken are very familiar with.

Comments are closed.